Пожалуйста, используйте этот идентификатор, чтобы цитировать или ссылаться на этот ресурс: https://open.mgimo.ru/handle/123456789/21806
Название: Study of Decision-making Issues in Social Groups Based on Modelling of Incomplete Consensus
Исследование вопросов принятия решений в социальных группах на основе моделирования неполного консенсуса
Авторы: Maksimova, O.V.
Aronov, I.Z.
Papić, L.
Максимова, О.В.
Аронов, И.З.
Папич, Л.
Ключевые слова: decision-making
social groups
consensus
incomplete consensus
modelling
group decision
European eco-settlements
social movements
international organizations
принятие решений
социальные группы
консенсус
неполный консенсус
моделирование
групповое решение
европейские эко-поселения
социальные движения
международные организации
Дата публикации: 2022
Библиографическое описание: Maksimova O. V., Aronov I. Z., Papić L. Study of Decision-making Issues in Social Groups Based on Modelling of Incomplete Consensus. Journal of Graphic Era University. 2022;10(1):-. https://doi.org/10.13052/jgeu0975-1416.1015
Максимова О. В., Аронов И. З., Папич Л. Исследование вопросов принятия решений в социальных группах на основе моделирования неполного консенсуса. Journal of Graphic Era University. 2022;10(1):-. https://doi.org/10.13052/jgeu0975-1416.1015
Аннотация: In many social groups, for example, in European eco-settlements, socialmovements (occupy), international organizations (WTO, OSCE, IPCC, etc.),decision-making is based on the consensus of the group members. Instead ofvoting, when the majority wins over the minority, consensus allows findinga solution that each member of the group supports or, at least, considersacceptable. This approach ensures that all the opinions of the group members,their ideas and needs will be taken into account. At the same time, reachinga consensus requires considerable time, since it is necessary to come toan agreement within the group, regardless of its size. It was shown that in some situations the number of iterations (agreements, negotiations) is verysignificant. Moreover, in the decision-making process, there is always a riskof blocking a decision by a minority in the group, which not only prolongs thedecision-making time but even makes it impossible. As a rule, such a minorityis presented by one or two odious people. Such a member of the group triesto dominate the discussion, always stands by his/her opinion, ignoring theposition of the others. This leads to a protraction in the decision-makingprocess, on the one hand, and a deterioration in the quality of consensus,on the other, since only the opinion of the dominant part of the group wouldbe taken into account.In order to overcome this problem, it was proposedto make a decision based on the principle of “Consensus Minus One” or“Consensus Minus Two”, that is, not to take into account the opinion of one ortwo odious members of the group. For example, in climate researches, wheremany scientific disciplines are involved, a complete consensus is almostimpossible.Based on the simulation of consensus using the Markov chain model, thearticle studies the question of how much the decision-making time is reducedwhen using the “Consensus Minus One” and “Consensus Minus Two” rules,if the position of the dominant members of the group is not taken into account.As it appears from the findings obtained, this paper can be in generalsummarized by saying that the rule of thumb applied for making a decisionpursuant to the incomplete consensus principle has a solid mathematicalbackground. The simulation results showed that its use can reduce the timerequired to reach a consensus to 97%, which is crucial for practice.The average number of agreements hyperbolically depends on the averageauthoritarianism of the group members (excluding the autocratic members),which means that the negotiation process can be protracted at high values ofthe above-mentioned average authoritarianism
Во многих социальных группах, например, в европейских эко-поселениях, социальных движениях (Occupy), международных организациях (ВТО, ОБСЕ, МГЭИК и др.), принятие решений основано на консенсусе членов группы. Вместо голосования, когда большинство побеждает меньшинство, консенсус позволяет найти решение, которое каждый член группы поддерживает или, по крайней мере, считает приемлемым. Такой подход гарантирует, что все мнения членов группы, их идеи и потребности будут учтены. В то же время...
URI: https://open.mgimo.ru/handle/123456789/21806
ISSN: 0975-1416
2456-4281
Располагается в коллекциях:Статьи сотрудников МГИМО во внешних журналах

Файлы этого ресурса:
Файл Описание РазмерФормат 
10.13052_jgeu0975-1416.1015.pdf1,05 MBAdobe PDFПросмотреть/Открыть
Источник: Journal of Graphic Era University  (2022)


Все ресурсы в архиве электронных ресурсов защищены авторским правом, все права сохранены.