Пожалуйста, используйте этот идентификатор, чтобы цитировать или ссылаться на этот ресурс:
https://open.mgimo.ru/handle/123456789/23023| Название: | Theory of Administrative Discretion: Comparative Legal Aspects Теория административного усмотрения: сравнительно-правовые аспекты |
| Авторы: | Sherstoboev, O.N. Шерстобоев, О.Н. |
| Ключевые слова: | administrative discretion judicial review discretionary administrative acts legal formalisation comparative legal analysis criteria for review legitimation административное усмотрение судебный контроль дискреционные административные акты юридическая формализация сравнительно-правовой анализ критерии пересмотра легитимация |
| Дата публикации: | 2025 |
| Библиографическое описание: | Sherstoboev O. N. Theory of Administrative Discretion: Comparative Legal Aspects. Siberian Law Review. 2025;22(4):584-599. https://doi.org/10.19073/2658-7602-2025-22-4-584-599 Шерстобоев О. Н. Теория административного усмотрения: сравнительно-правовые аспекты. Siberian Law Review. 2025;22(4):584-599. https://doi.org/10.19073/2658-7602-2025-22-4-584-599 |
| Аннотация: | The legitimation of administrative discretion is closely linked to empowering courts to review discretionary administrative acts. At the same time, a system of criteria designed to enable such review emerged. This article examines the key and several supplementary criteria used by courts to assess administrative discretion, demonstrates methods of their legal formalisation, and draws conclusions regarding the most appropriate and effective methods. The primary methodology employed is comparative legal analysis. This approach makes it possible to examine the models for legal formalization of these criteria in Austria, Germany, France, and several Central Asian countries, and to compare them with Russian judicial practice and legislation. The Author concludes that administrative discretion should not be institutionalised as a separate institution of administrative law, as doing so risks eroding its essential characteristics and diminishing the effectiveness of public administration. In all countries studied, discretion enters administrative law through criteria that limit it and thereby enable courts to review the legality of discretionary administrative acts. The main criteria are the lawful purpose and scope of powers of administrative bodies, while additional criteria consist of general principles of administrative law (administrative procedure). These principles have been developed by courts and scholarly schools and are closely tied to constitutional provisions. Therefore, there is no need for their codification; statutory definitions would merely restate well-known principles and would not add anything substantively new. Codification is justified only when a principle is absent from the legal system and the legislator is introducing it for the first time. Importantly, even once a principle has been codified, it will still require judicial interpretation; courts will continue to refine its meaning and methods of application. In Russia, the main principles, including proportionality and the protection of legitimate expectations, have long been recognised by courts and doctrine. They are affirmed in the decisions of the Constitutional Court, which the Supreme Court follows. Nonetheless, the Russian legislator continues to codify them in various statutes, including legislation on state control. The Author concludes that the Supreme Court should apply these principles more actively when reviewing administrative discretion. In particular, the protection of legitimate expectations requires greater attention from the Plenum of the Supreme Court. Легитимация административного усмотрения тесно связана с наделением судов полномочиями по пересмотру дискреционных административных актов. В то же время возникла система критериев, предназначенных для обеспечения такого пересмотра. В данной статье рассматриваются ключевые и несколько дополнительных критериев, используемых судами для оценки административного усмотрения, демонстрируются методы их юридической формализации и делаются выводы относительно наиболее подходящих и эффективных методов. Основная используемая методология — сравнительная... |
| URI: | https://open.mgimo.ru/handle/123456789/23023 |
| ISSN: | 2658-7602 2658-7610 |
| Располагается в коллекциях: | Статьи сотрудников МГИМО во внешних журналах |
Файлы этого ресурса:
| Файл | Описание | Размер | Формат | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10.19073_2658-7602-2025-22-4-584-599.pdf | 447,05 kB | Adobe PDF | Просмотреть/Открыть |
Источник:
Siberian Law Review
(2025)
Все ресурсы в архиве электронных ресурсов защищены авторским правом, все права сохранены.